AI today Work and society

Replaced by AI, then called back: why some companies are reversing course

In a US survey almost one worker in five says they were replaced by AI and then asked back. Why it happens, what people want in return and why it is not a U-turn.

· 1:01 video · English voiceover with English captions.

The news

Some companies that replaced workers with artificial intelligence are now calling them back. That is the finding of a survey by SHL, a talent assessment company, released on 29 October 2026 and covered by CNBC and Fortune. The research, run by Propeller Insights in June and July with more than a thousand workers in the US and more than a thousand in the UK, gave the trend a name: AI rebounding.

In the US, 19.1% of respondents said they had been replaced by AI and then asked back by the same employer: almost one in five. Among 18 to 24 year olds the share rises to 24%. Across the US and UK together it is 16%.

Five simple figures, only one in colour, with the words "1 in 5" and "replaced, then asked back".

Why companies call back

Another survey, by Robert Half of about 2,000 US hiring managers, points the same way: 32% said their organisation had restored roles it had eliminated because of AI or automation.

Three reasons come up most. 40% mention institutional knowledge and context that AI lacks: what a person knows about a client, a process, or who to call when something goes wrong, which often isn't written down anywhere. 38% say more oversight and quality control was needed than expected. 35% say productivity gains fell short.

A person next to a note: "Not written anywhere. Which client wants what. Why we do it this way. Who to call."
A checklist and two bars: the hoped-for gains tall, the real ones much shorter.

What workers want

People who are asked back don't return on the same terms. According to SHL, 51% would ask for a substantial raise, 42% for written job security, 40% for full transparency on how AI will be used in their role and 30% for an apology from leadership. Only 6.6% of US workers say they would refuse under any circumstances.

Lucy Beaumont of SHL told CNBC that companies "pulled the plug too quickly" and that with those people "you've really broken the trust".

Two demands: 51% a big raise, 42% job security in writing.

The other side

This is not a general U-turn. According to Challenger, Gray & Christmas, US employers cited AI in 121,401 announced job cuts in 2026 through October, about 20% of all cuts. In October, though, AI was cited for only 1,265 cuts, its lowest monthly total of the year, and economic conditions have overtaken it as the leading reason.

For young people the picture is harder. The Stanford Digital Economy Lab found that employment among 22 to 25 year olds in highly AI-exposed jobs is about 19% below where it would be if it had kept pace with peers in less-exposed jobs. The same authors say they "do not see widespread, economy-wide job displacement associated with AI" and that their figures are "descriptive patterns, not causal estimates".

Then there are the limits of surveys. SHL's records what people say, not verified data: it doesn't say how "replaced by AI" was defined or whether employers accepted the demands. And SHL sells hiring services, so it has a stake in the topic.

A counter stopped at 121,401, with the words "US job cuts that cited AI in 2026".

Bottom line

Replacing people with AI doesn't always work: what people know is not that easy to replace.

Two stamps: "Replacing people" and "doesn't always work".

Sources

Video transcript

Some companies replaced workers with artificial intelligence. Now they're calling them back. In an American survey, almost one in five said it happened to them: replaced, then asked back. Among eighteen to twenty-four year olds, it's one in four. Why? In another survey, about a third of hiring managers brought back roles they had cut for AI. The top reason: what people know that isn't written down anywhere. Then more checking than expected, and smaller gains. And the workers? Many won't come back on the same terms. Half are asking for a big raise. Four in ten, for job security in writing. But careful: this is not a U-turn. This year, American companies have cited AI in more than a hundred and twenty thousand job cuts. Young people in the jobs most exposed to AI are also finding less work than their peers. And these are surveys: people's own accounts, not verified records. So: replacing people with AI doesn't always work. What people know is not that easy to replace.

Read next